Movies featuring female superheroes have had a lot of trouble at the box office.
With the exception of the first Wonder Woman movie (starring Gal Gadot), many of the others have ranged from barely adequate to disastrous. This is only regarding the box office. Many have been critical successes, earning considerable accolades from film critics.
Part of the problem comes from what I would call "male comic fans in theory." They're often men who are more familiar with superheroes via television, movies, toy figures, video games, and cosplay,
Even some comic fans are fixated on one era of the superhero, rather than the totality of its presentation.
Some are fixated on female characters whose physicality and sexual allure are emphasized. Supergirl had only one such period, when she was drawn by Michael Turner in the 2000s.
For the most part, Supergirl has been portrayed as the girl next door. Starting in the 50s, she took on many aspects of the time she was written in, updating as the culture updated. I would say that Supergirl has had more revisions and changes than almost every other superhero. And that's saying a lot.
Many of the "fans" who shout, "That is not Supergirl!" are rejecting other versions.
Through all the changes, other than the Turner era, she's meant to be pretty but not Va-Va-Voom. Her appeal is designed to be as much to young girls as to boys. Her problems in the 50s were typical of that time. She was very caring and empathetic, liking boys but not overly obsessed with them.
The movie version is based on the graphic novel Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow. This is a grittier version of Supergirl. Unlike Superman, she witnessed the destruction of her home planet, Krypton, as a young girl. The only part of Krypton to survive was Argo City, a domed city that was also eventually destroyed. She survived aboard a rocket ship, heading to Earth, where she would be a protector of the infant Kal-El (Superman). She lost everyone she knew and loved, including her parents, and, through time anomalies, arrived on Earth after Kal-El had become a full-grown adult. Think carefully, Someone who had been through this would be suffering from a lot of trauma and PTSD, wouldn't you think? Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow is the story that most fully acknowledges this.
This Supergirl is traveling the cosmos, often seeking out worlds under a red sun, where she does not have her powers, where she is not invulnerable, where she can feel things. She can drink and get drunk. She can feel pain. Heck, she can even get hers pierced or a tattoo.*
She looks disheveled and not perfectly put together.
This is the version that Milly Alcock has been hired to portray. And by early critical accounts, she is outstanding in that role, a true highlight of the film.
Yet, the incel army continues to carp.By any human standard of beauty, Milly Alcock is gorgeous. It is to her amazing abilities that she can portray Kara (Supergirl) as she is meant to be in this story. Someone in a lot of pain, trying to find the balance between the trauma she has gone through, and still trying to live up to the impossible standards of goodness and valor she sees in her cousin, Kal-El,
I am currently reading a collection of the earliest Supergirl stories, starting in the fifties. I am also re-reading Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow. And over the years, I have read everything in between. Next to Superman, she is mt favorite DC superhero.
I am very much looking forward to seeing Supergirl in the theatres as soon as I can get out to it.
I wish a lot of people would see it. I want to see more of director Jame Gunn's DCU.
But I am scared that the incels and comic snobs are going to win,
So, if you are a moviegoer, if you like superheroes, if you saw Barbie, please come see this movie.
A failure here could cost us not just the DCU but female-empowerment movies in general.
I hope to see you there!
*Yes, some have harped at a picture of Milly Alcock as Supergirl wearing earrings. It's true that normally Supergirl's skin would be impervious to piercing, but that's only under a yellow sun. With a red sun, it is possible, and something I think Kara would want to do. So there, you part-time fans/wankers!


.webp)
.webp)








.webp)